If staff have pulled vehicles from logs alone in less hostile situations, which they have.. MANY MANY times... then you have to accept that no opinions on how the fight would have played out, and no other intervening factors should have any say whatsoever in him losing his ghawk. Letting him keep it was bias, and nobody has ever come close to making an argument to refute that.
A shitty half cocked defense was made for him, and it was pushed through by shutting the matter down and refusing to discuss it. No member of staff has been able to make a single argument against that. They know they are wrong.... and the problem here is people who won't consider better arguments because their mind is made up despite all precedent to the contrary.
If you can't look at the situation, and the arguments made against it and even consider that you're wrong, then how are are the good staff supposed to be better than the bad staff?
Logic suggests there are only two possible reasons that kid isn't getting his ghawk ripped:
1. Ego and pride stopping GG from admitting he's wrong about the situation.
2. There is bias for this kid.