Miranda Rights For The APD

[Nixon Jones 182]

Should the Miranda rights be included for the APD for when someone is being arrested? For me it would give a bit better chance for the role-play to happen between the officer and the offender. What do you all think?

[bigSMOKE 924]

no

[Nixon Jones 182]

1 hour ago, bigSMOKE said:

no

You got a point to prove or just a certain answer?

[JBruesch 483]

25 minutes ago, Wonderwaffle said:

Should the Miranda rights be included for the APD for when someone is being arrested? For me it would give a bit better chance for the role-play to happen between the officer and the offender. What do you all think?

No, as the Miranda rights are an American thing, and Altis is in Greece. The closest we could get is something similar, but an Olympus version, but I know it would just be another thing Civs would demand a pardon for if the Deputy forgets it.

[Trimorphious 427]

Shouldn't be a rule, should be up to you. If you wanna read someone their Miranda rights when you arrest them go for it, pretty good RP imo.

[Guest G.O.A.T.]

I'd rather kill myself if I'm being honest, but hey if someone wants to do it with you for a good time of RP...go for it.

[Guest]

I have a great idea!

 

MORE BEUARACRACY!

[TheRandomOne 477]

Here's how I see it going:

Officer tazes and restrains someone

Officer: You have the right to remain silent...

*they start getting salty and shouting shit*

Officer:....but you do not have the ability

 

 

 

Actually, that sounds fun. I might do that.

[Ajax 643]

I'm going to start saying my own rights... "you have the right to fuck yourself over, oh wait you just did that"

[-dante- 5321]

My opinion is the moment we make it mandatory is the time everybody starts throwing every single American Law into their RP and I will probably drown in my own pity from it. Plz no.

[Nixon Jones 182]

This doesn't have to be mandatory, you may just say it for your own RP experience.

[Toasty 1564]

 

[PoptartRex 3294]

@Wonderwaffle

Make your own Miranda rights! Call them the Waffle rights. Makes for a more unique RP story. 

Post it on the forums when you are done!!!

[Julian 142]

4 minutes ago, TheCmdrRex said:

@Wonderwaffle

Make your own Miranda rights! Call them the Waffle rights. Makes for a more unique RP story. 

Post it on the forums when you are done!!!

That actually sounds pretty because we would not have to add american laws into this but we would have a better RP experience when read them rights

[MrRonSwanson 76]

Miranda rights should be as follows

1. You have the obligation to shut the fuck up when we are talking to you

 

2. You will not complain when PO's let their deputies kick you on the balls.

 

3. We are APD. We are legion. We do not forgive. we do not forget.

 

4. No lawyers, so catch me outside. How bout DAT?

 

5. Do you understand these rights? Actually we dont give a fuck. Pay up or go to jail.

[Lithium1056 2]

To be fair quite a few countries have equivalent versions of the Miranda rights. Not All of which required massive police fuck ups to enact. 

 

All in all could be pretty fun for RP but at the end of the day the Judicial system on Altis is arrest or death. There isn't any real in between for the guilty parties. 

[RAYRAY 273]

YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO REMAIN SILENT 

 

ANY RP WILL BE USED AGAINST YOU 

 

YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO AN ATTORNY BUT IT WILL MORE THAN LIKELY BE UN ACKNOWLEDGED AS RP 

 

I HAVE THE RIGHT TO ADD CHARGES 

 

LIKELY STORY, OKAY SIR I WILL BE SENDING YOU TO JAIL LOL SORRY NO I CANT REDUCE THE TICKET 

[Danger 729]

This would be aids. This is Altis, you have no rights!

[Atonomy 18]

-1 not good, I don't want to read someone their rights while there 6 rebel buddies tryin to kill me and if i don't when i restrain them ill prob forget tbh. or in pd hearing all the aids comms from rebels while officers trying to read right yea right

[KingMango 21]

On ‎3‎/‎2‎/‎2017 at 10:20 PM, JBruesch said:

No, as the Miranda rights are an American thing, and Altis is in Greece. The closest we could get is something similar, but an Olympus version, but I know it would just be another thing Civs would demand a pardon for if the Deputy forgets it.

I agree completely and shit gets hard enough when u have some kid screaming in your ear while your trying to process.

[Stelar 225]

1. There are now lawyers on altis

2. What people say cannot be taken in as evidence as per the handbook

[javins beast 36]

It would give a better RP experience but it would be another thing deputes that are new would have to learn and forget.